“The
long-term success and sustainability of project teams require motivating
behaviors from project managers”(Portny,
Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton & Kramer, 2008, p. 310). One major key to success is good communication
or “sharing the right messages with the right people in a timely manner”(Portny
et al., 2008, p. 367). The chart below
evaluates three different modes of communication for the same message as
presented at this LINK
in my graduate course studies this week.
Mode of Communication
|
My Interpretation of Message
|
Factors Influencing my Perception
|
Text Email Mode
|
Jane
needs Mark’s report soon, but it is not necessarily an urgent priority.
|
-Text
email let me take my own time to read or re-read the message.
-There
was no bolded or numbered specifics to the
task request.
-The
request gets a bit lost in all the words.
|
Audio Voice Mail Mode
|
A
personal friend needs Mark’s report urgently.
|
-Tone
of voice was personal and friendly, but a bit stressed and rushed.
-Wording
was rapid and voice evidenced emotion that caught my attention. Voice sounded very appreciative.
-I
had to replay the message, however, to discover what the actual request was
asking for: ETA data. That detail got
lost in the rush of sound.
|
Video Face to Face Mode
|
A
professional colleague requests Mark's ETA report as soon as
convenient.
|
-Co-worker’s
face to face presence and smile was friendly and subdued.
-Eye
contact was hard to ignore, but warm and not urgent. Her in person presence distracted a bit
from her message.
-Tone
of voice was sort of sing song, so the message did not feel super urgent.
|
Synthesis of Thoughts
For
this particular message, the most effective mode of delivery for me was the
audio mode in the voice mail. That’s
because I sensed both a sense of urgency and a sense of gratitude in the person’s
recorded voice. Both those tonal
messages hit me more deeply than the other two modes because I felt an
emotional connection to the person requesting the report. This little message mode activity has taught
me to carefully consider customizing all my communications according to task
and audience in a project. “Communication can be formal or informal, written or
verbal. Whatever form communications take, however, project managers should
plan and prepare so their messages are received and correctly interpreted by
project audiences”(Portny et al., 2008, p. 367).
I
also learned that while email communications help people record, document and
keep track of communications, a lot of the message can be lost inside a text
paragraph. I realize that project managers cannot avoid this mode of
communication, but I also now realize that selecting that right moment for a
voice message can help to create a sense of friendly urgency when needed. “While
managers today typically write fewer memos than 10 years ago, nearly all project
managers must write some type of report on a regular basis – as well as dozens
of emails each day”(Portny et al, 2008, p. 371). That’s why I think we are lucky to have the
podcasting tool for conducting team communications as well.
Our
course text even provides an example of using podcasts for regular team
communications on page 365, which can also be found at this LINK.
This manager tools website provides many helpful and downloadable podcasts that
deliver accompanying tools such as project delegation worksheets, meeting agenda
templates and effective email outlines, all for successfully coordinating the
behemoth of communications in any project.
References
Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J.,
Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B. E. (2008).
Project
management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects.
Hoboken, NJ:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Hello Sheila, I really love the was you laid out the information into a table format. It helps to clearly distingiush the difference between the three modalities. In looking back, the voice mail did seem to be the most effective mode of communication the tone was noce but it also let the person know that they needed to submit the data and fast! As for the email mode of communication, I believe that should be used as more of a follow up method after oral communication because emails tend to get lost.
ReplyDeleteHi Sheila,
ReplyDeleteThis is Jeff. Wanted to let you know I sent you an email message (to your Walden account). Sorry to post this here but I wanted to make sure you get the email as it is important.
BTW - I enjoyed reading your blog and appreciate the use of the table to layout the communications related to each method.
:-)
-jeff
Hi Jeff!
DeleteOnce more I can't thank you enough for your email to me about my comment posted to your blog!
:-)
Sheila